LOGO

Spring vs Foam Mattress: Which One is Better for You?

Picture of Quinlan
Quinlan

July 24, 2024

Spring vs Foam mattress

Do you often wake up feeling more tired than when you went to bed? Choosing the right mattress may be essential for a restful night’s sleep. Knowing the differences between spring and foam mattresses can help you make a well-informed decision.

Whether you are considering a foam vs spring mattress, each has its unique advantages and potential drawbacks. Spring mattresses, known for their durability and support, use metal coils to provide a firm, bouncy feel. 

In contrast, foam mattresses, particularly memory foam, offer excellent pressure relief by adapting to your body shape. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each mattress type, helping you determine which one is better suited for your sleep style and comfort.

Table of Content

What is a Spring Mattress?

A spring mattress, also known as an innerspring mattress, is a traditional type of mattress that has been popular for over a century. It features a core support system made of metal coils or springs, which provide a firm and bouncy feel. The coils are often topped with layers of padding to enhance comfort. 

Spring mattresses are recognized for their durability and their capacity to provide strong support. This makes them a preferred choice for those who need a firmer sleeping surface. They also tend to sleep cooler compared to foam mattresses, as the open coil structure allows for better airflow.

Construction and Materials of Spring Mattresses

Spring mattresses feature a core system of metal coils that deliver the main support. These coils can vary in design, such as Bonnell, offset, continuous, or pocketed coils. Each offers different levels of support and durability. The coils are connected and form a strong support network that helps maintain the mattress’s shape and longevity.

On top of the coil system, spring mattresses typically feature various layers of padding made from materials like foam, latex, or fiber. These layers enhance comfort by adding cushioning and a soft surface for sleepers. The combination of the coil system and the comfort layers determines the overall feel and performance of the mattress.

The edge support in spring mattresses is often reinforced to prevent bowing. It provides a stable sitting or sleeping surface across the entire mattress. The materials used in the comfort layers and the type of coils chosen significantly influence the mattress’s firmness, responsiveness, and breathability.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Spring Mattresses

Benefits:

  • Support and Durability: Spring mattresses are known for their strong support system. This helps maintain spinal alignment and reduces the risk of back pain. A strong coil structure ensures the mattress remains durable and maintains its shape over time. If you are comparing foam vs spring mattresses for back pain, this support can be crucial.
  • Affordability: Generally, spring mattresses are more budget-friendly compared to foam or hybrid options.
  • Cooling: The open coil design promotes better airflow, which helps regulate temperature and keeps the mattress cool. This provides a more comfortable sleep environment.
  • Bounce and Responsiveness: The inherent bounciness of springs offers a responsive feel. This makes it easier to move and change sleeping positions without feeling stuck.

Drawbacks:

  • Pressure Relief: Spring mattresses might not offer the same degree of pressure relief as foam mattresses. This can be a disadvantage for side sleepers or those with joint pain, as the springs may create pressure points.
  • Motion Transfer: Innerspring mattresses can transfer motion more easily than foam mattresses. This can be noticeable if you share the bed with a partner who moves frequently during the night.
  • Noise: Over time, the coils in spring mattresses can start to squeak, which might be bothersome for light sleepers.
  • Wear and Tear: The comfort layers on top of the springs can wear out more quickly, leading to indentations in the mattress. This can compromise comfort and support over time.

What is a Foam Mattress?

A foam mattress, especially memory foam, offers superior comfort by conforming to your body shape. Made entirely from layers of foam like memory foam, polyurethane, or latex, these mattresses provide excellent pressure relief. They evenly distribute body weight, reducing pressure points and motion isolation, making them a popular choice among those comparing spring vs foam mattresses. Foam mattresses are also often hypoallergenic. Modern foam mattresses also incorporate cooling technologies to reduce heat retention. This ensures a cool, comfortable sleep environment. This combination of support, comfort, and innovation makes foam mattresses a popular choice. They provide a restful sleep experience.

Construction and Materials of Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses are constructed with multiple layers of various foam types to provide a balanced combination of support, comfort, and durability. The primary types of foam used in these mattresses include memory foam, polyurethane foam, and latex foam.

  1. Memory Foam: This viscoelastic material is renowned for its capacity to mold to the body, offering customized support and alleviating pressure points. Memory foam reacts to body heat, softening and molding to the sleeper’s shape.
  2. Polyurethane Foam: Often used as the base layer in foam mattresses, polyurethane foam offers firm support and helps maintain the mattress’s structure. It can also be found in varying densities to adjust the firmness and durability of the mattress.
  3. Latex Foam: Derived from natural or synthetic latex, this foam provides a responsive and slightly bouncy feel. It is known for its durability and natural resistance to dust mites and mold, making it a good option for allergy sufferers.
  4. Cooling Technologies: Many modern foam mattresses incorporate cooling gels, open-cell structures, or phase-change materials. These improvements enhance breathability and regulate temperature, addressing foam mattresses’ common heat retention issue.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Foam Mattresses

Benefits:

  1. Pressure Relief: Foam mattresses, especially memory foam, provide pressure relief. They do this by conforming to the body and distributing weight evenly. This helps reduce pressure points, which is beneficial for those with joint pain or specific sleeping positions.
  2. Motion Isolation: Foam mattresses absorb movement exceptionally well, making them an ideal choice for couples. This feature minimizes disturbances caused by a partner’s movements during the night.
  3. Comfort and Support: The ability of foam to conform to the body’s shape provides customized support and comfort. This enhances overall sleep quality.
  4. Hypoallergenic: Many foam mattresses are resistant to allergens such as dust mites and mold.
  5. Versatility: Foam mattresses come in various firmness levels and constructions.

Drawbacks:

  1. Heat Retention: Traditional memory foam mattresses can trap heat, making them less suitable for hot sleepers. Many modern foam mattresses incorporate cooling technologies to reduce this issue.
  2. Initial Odor: Foam mattresses, particularly those made with synthetic materials, can emit a chemical smell, known as off-gassing when first discharged.
  3. Weight: Foam mattresses can be quite heavy and difficult to move, especially in larger sizes.
  4. Firmness Levels: Foam mattresses offer various firmness options. They may not provide the same level of support as traditional innerspring mattresses for some sleepers.
  5. Cost: High-quality foam mattresses, especially those with advanced cooling technologies or multiple foam layers, can be more expensive. This is compared to traditional spring mattresses.

Comparison: Spring vs. Foam Mattresses

Support and Comfort

  • Spring Mattresses: Known for their firm support, spring mattresses use metal coils to maintain structure and provide a bouncy feel. They are ideal for those who prefer a firmer surface and often for back sleepers. The coils offer strong support and are beneficial for maintaining proper spinal alignment.
  • Foam Mattresses: Foam mattresses, especially memory foam, offer exceptional conforming to the body. They provide personalized support and pressure relief. They are particularly good for side sleepers and those with joint pain. The foam evenly distributes body weight and reduces pressure points.

Motion Isolation

  • Spring Mattresses: Generally, spring mattresses do not excel in motion isolation. The interconnected coils can transfer movement across the bed, potentially disturbing a partner during the night.​ 
  • Foam Mattresses: Foam mattresses, particularly memory foam, are known for their excellent motion isolation. They absorb movement and minimize disturbances, making them a popular choice for couples.

Temperature Regulation

  • Spring Mattresses: The open coil structure of spring mattresses allows for better airflow. This helps regulate temperature and keeps the mattress cooler.​
  • Foam Mattresses: Traditional foam mattresses tend to retain heat, which can be uncomfortable for hot sleepers. Many modern foam mattresses incorporate cooling technologies. These include gel-infused foam or open-cell structures, improving breathability and heat retention management.

Durability and Lifespan

  • Spring Mattresses: Spring mattresses are generally durable, but their longevity depends on the quality of the coils and materials used. Over time, the coils can lose their shape and lead to sagging.
  • Foam Mattresses: High-quality foam mattresses can be very durable and maintain their shape and support for many years. Lower-quality foam can degrade more quickly, leading to indentations and a decrease in support.

Price Range

  • Spring Mattresses: Typically more affordable than foam mattresses, spring mattresses are a good option for budget-conscious consumers. The price can vary depending on the coil type and the additional comfort layers.
  • Foam Mattresses: Foam mattresses, especially those with advanced technologies or multiple layers, can be more expensive. They often provide better comfort and support, which can justify the higher cost.

Overall Preference

  • Spring Mattresses: Best for those who prefer a traditional, firmer, and bouncier mattress. It also offers good airflow and cooling properties. They are also more budget-friendly and offer strong support for back sleepers.​ 
  • Foam Mattresses: Perfect for those who desire exceptional pressure relief, customized support, and outstanding motion isolation. They suit side sleepers, couples, and individuals with joint pain. Modern foam mattresses also address the issue of heat retention, making them a versatile choice.

By weighing these factors, you can decide which type of mattress best suits your sleep preferences and needs.

Who Should Choose a Spring Mattress?

Back Sleepers: Spring mattresses provide firm support, which is beneficial for back sleepers. The coils help maintain spinal alignment, reducing the risk of back pain.

Hot Sleepers: If you tend to sleep hot, a spring mattress might be a better choice. The open coil structure promotes airflow, keeping the mattress cooler. This provides a more comfortable sleep environment.

Budget-Conscious Shoppers: Generally, spring mattresses are more affordable than foam mattresses. They offer a good balance of support and comfort at a lower price point, making them accessible to a wide range of consumers.

Those Who Prefer a Bouncy Feel: The natural bounce of a spring mattress can make it easier to move and change positions during the night. This responsive feel is preferred by many who find foam mattresses too conforming or restrictive.

People Seeking Durability: High-quality spring mattresses, particularly those with pocketed coils, can be very durable and maintain support for many years. They are less likely to develop indentations and lose their shape compared to some foam mattresses.

Individuals Who Experience Night Sweats: The breathability of a spring mattress can help wick away moisture and provide a cooler, drier sleep surface. This can be particularly beneficial for those who experience night sweats.

Combination Sleepers: If you change positions often during the night, a spring mattress provides responsive support. This accommodates different sleeping positions without feeling stuck.

Who Should Choose a Foam Mattress?

Side Sleepers: Foam mattresses, particularly memory foam, excel at providing pressure relief by contouring the body’s shape. This can alleviate pressure points on the shoulders and hips, making it ideal for side sleepers.

Couples: Foam mattresses are known for their excellent motion isolation. If you share a bed with a partner who moves a lot during the night, a foam mattress will minimize disturbances, allowing for a more restful sleep.

Individuals with Joint Pain: Foam mattresses offer personalized support, reducing pain in pressure-sensitive areas. This makes them a good choice for those with arthritis or other joint issues.

Those Seeking Hypoallergenic Options: Many foam mattresses are resistant to allergens such as dust mites and mold. 

People Who Prefer a Soft: Foam mattresses, especially those made with memory foam, offer a plush, enveloping feel. This is great for those who prefer a mattress that conforms closely to their body for added comfort.

Light Sleepers: Because foam mattresses absorb and isolate movement, they are ideal for light sleepers. This feature helps those who are easily disturbed by their partner’s movements or other disruptions.

Better Spinal Alignment: Foam mattresses can provide excellent support for the spine. They promote better spinal alignment and reduce the risk of back pain.

Technology Enthusiasts: Modern foam mattresses often incorporate advanced materials and technologies. These include gel-infused foam or open-cell structures to enhance cooling and breathability.

Hybrid Mattresses: The Best of Both Worlds?

Hybrid mattresses combine the best features of both spring and foam mattresses to offer a balanced sleep experience. By integrating a core of innerspring coils with layers of foam, they aim to provide enhanced comfort, support, and durability. Here’s a closer look at why hybrid mattresses are often considered the best of both worlds:

Support and Comfort:

  • Balanced Support: Hybrid mattresses typically feature a base layer of pocketed coils, which offer strong support and maintain spinal alignment. This is particularly beneficial for those who need extra support but also want the comfort of foam.
  • Enhanced Comfort: The top layers usually consist of memory foam, latex, or gel-infused foam. These materials contour to the body, providing pressure relief and a plush sleeping surface. This is ideal for side sleepers and those with joint pain.

Temperature Regulation:

  • Breathability: The coil system in hybrid mattresses allows for better airflow compared to all-foam mattresses. This helps to reduce heat and keep the mattress cool. Many hybrid mattresses incorporate cooling technologies in the foam layers. These may include gel infusions or open-cell structures to enhance breathability and regulate temperature.

Motion Isolation and Responsiveness:

  • Motion Isolation: Foam layers help minimize motion transfer, the pocketed coils in hybrid mattresses absorb and isolate movement. This makes them an excellent choice for couples seeking undisturbed sleep.
  • Responsiveness: The coil system provides a responsive feel, making it easier to move and change positions during the night. This bounce-back feature is similar to that of traditional innerspring mattresses but with the added comfort of foam.

Durability and Longevity:

  • Enhanced Durability: This helps it maintain its shape and support over time. Hybrid mattresses often last longer than traditional innerspring or all-foam mattresses.
  • Edge Support: Hybrid mattresses usually offer reinforced edges, providing a stable surface. This is beneficial for those who sit on the edge of the bed frequently or need a larger sleeping surface.

Suitability for Various Sleepers:

  • Versatile Firmness Options: Hybrid mattresses come in various firmness levels, and support different sleep preferences and body types. Whether you prefer a soft, medium, or firm mattress, there’s likely a hybrid option to suit your needs.
  • Ideal for Combination Sleepers: Hybrid mattresses blend support and comfort. They are ideal for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night. They offer the pressure relief needed for side sleeping and the support required for back or stomach sleeping.

Selecting Foam vs. Spring Mattress for Your Needs

When exploring mattress options, spring vs foam mattresses IKEA offers a variety of choices to suit different preferences and budgets. IKEA’s mattress range includes affordable spring and advanced foam mattresses, ensuring you can find the right balance of comfort and support for a restful night’s sleep.

Foam Mattresses

Pros:

  1. Comfort and Support: Foam mattresses, especially memory foam, conform to your body, providing personalized support and relieving pressure points.
  2. Motion Isolation: They are excellent at minimizing motion transfer, making them ideal if you share your bed with a partner.
  3. Hypoallergenic: Foam mattresses generally resist allergens like dust mites, mold, and pet dander.

Cons:

  1. Heat Retention: Some foam mattresses can trap heat, leading to a warmer sleeping surface.
  2. Initial Off-Gassing: New foam mattresses may emit a chemical smell initially, though this usually dissipates after a few days.
  3. Edge Support: They often lack strong edge support, which can be an issue if you sit or sleep near the edge of the bed.

Spring Mattresses

Pros:

  1. Breathability: Spring mattresses generally have better airflow, keeping the sleeping surface cooler.
  2. Support: They provide firmer support, which can be beneficial for those with back pain or who prefer a firmer sleeping surface.
  3. Bounce: Spring mattresses tend to be more bouncy, which some people prefer for ease of movement.

Cons:

  1. Motion Transfer: They can transfer more motion, which might disturb a partner if one of you moves frequently during the night.
  2. Durability: Springs can wear out over time, potentially leading to sagging or noise.
  3. Comfort: They might not conform to your body as well as foam, which can result in pressure points for some sleepers.

Factors to Consider

  1. Sleeping Position:
    • Side Sleepers: Foam mattresses can provide better pressure relief for shoulders and hips.
    • Back and Stomach Sleepers: A firmer spring mattress may offer the support needed to keep the spine aligned.
  2. Body Weight:
    • Heavier Individuals: Might prefer the support and durability of a spring mattress.
    • Lighter Individuals: May find foam mattresses more comfortable and supportive.
  3. Budget: Foam mattresses, particularly high-quality memory foam, can be more expensive. Spring mattresses vary widely in price but are generally more affordable.
  • Temperature Sensitivity: If you tend to sleep hot, a spring mattress might be a better choice due to its breathability.

FAQs: Spring vs Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses, especially memory foam, are often recommended for back pain. Foam mattresses mold to the body, delivering focused support. This helps maintain spinal alignment and reduces pressure points effectively.

Yes, traditional foam mattresses can retain body heat, which may cause them to sleep warmer. However, many modern foam mattresses incorporate cooling technologies to reduce this issue.

The durability of a spring mattress vs foam mattress which is better depends on the quality of the materials used. High-quality spring mattresses and hybrid models typically maintain their structure well over time.

Spring mattresses are generally more budget-friendly than foam mattresses. However, the price varies widely depending on the brand, materials, and added features of both types.

Foam mattresses, especially memory foam, excel in minimizing motion transfer. This makes them a better choice for couples seeking undisturbed sleep. Spring mattresses tend to transfer more motion due to their coil structure.

Conclusion

Deciding between a spring mattress and a foam mattress depends on your individual sleep preferences and needs. Spring mattresses offer strong support and excellent cooling. They also provide a traditional bouncy feel, making them ideal for back sleepers, hot sleepers, and those on a budget. On the other hand, Foam mattresses provide exceptional pressure relief and motion isolation. They also offer personalized comfort, making them perfect for side sleepers, couples, and individuals with joint pain.

To make a smart choice that improves your sleep quality, think about your sleeping position, body type, comfort preferences, and any specific health concerns. These factors will help you decide wisely. Remember, the right mattress can significantly impact your overall health and well-being.

We hope this comparison has provided you with valuable insights to help you choose the best mattress for your needs. If you have any questions or require additional help, we’d be happy to assist you! Did you find the information helpful? Share your thoughts and experiences with us in the comments below.

Picture of Quinlan

Quinlan

Quinlan, an esteemed Sleep Wellness Expert at Sleep Advisory, harnesses advanced sleep science to redefine sleep quality. His groundbreaking research and collaboration with leading experts underscore his expertise, offering robust, evidence-based advice for transformative sleep. Trust in Quinlan's proven strategies for achieving unparalleled restorative rest. For inquiries or personalized sleep consultation services, reach out to Quinlan at quinlan@sleepadvisory.com
Table of Content

Cons of Firm Mattress

Who Should Choose a Spring Mattress?

We Want to Hear From You!

Excited? Disagree? Curious? Whatever’s on your mind, we want to hear it! Your thoughts make our day and help us improve. So, go ahead, share away in the comments below. Let’s make Sleep Advisory even more awesome together!

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Twitter Linkedin Instagram Pinterest

Sleep Advisory may earn commissions on links to products. This doesn’t affect our reviews. For more, read our Affiliate Disclosure.

Mattress

About

Subscribe Now

Unlock Exclusive Sleep Tips and Mattress Insights!
© 2024 Sleep Advisory | Powered by Sleep Advisory